Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ednaldo Silva's avatar

Let’s not forget that China, like Russia, has the resources to implement the Roman solution to the ambitions of Hannibal. The stressed Romans burned Carthage during the Punic Wars, while Hannibal was stuck crossing the Pyrenees. China is not Vietnam, or Iraq, or Afghanistan, that didn’t have the STEM, trade surplus, manufacturing, and military might to hit back any intended U.S. aggression. Minus the apologetics, I agree with the prudent author that we must look at our umbilical cord, re-industrialize, and protect the homeland. Above all, we must stop being bullies poking the bear, because pandas can bite.

Expand full comment
Chet Nagle's avatar

David Pyne is an accomplished geopolitician who deserves all the accolades he has received. With regard to Taiwan he is absolutely correct -- the United States would not survive a war with communist China. Neither would China. We must not forget the words of Lt. General Gregory Newbold USMC (ret) "Wars must be waged only with stone-cold pragmatism, not idealism, and fought only when critical national interests are at stake." That is the ONLY justification for sending our soldiers, sailors and airmen to war. I wrote an article published in AND Magazine about Taiwan that shows the fallacy of the neocon desire to go to war with China -- ignoring the certainty that the least they will do is punch our lights out with a massive EMP strike. Read it here: https://andmagazine.substack.com/cp/134747722 and understand how correct David Pyne is in his assessment of the Taiwan issue.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts